As the Goodfellas skipper since 2008, Sidoti has strived to put a championship caliber team on the field each year. He has led the Goodfellas to the post season 3 out of 4 seasons as manager and also serves as the team’s first basemen. Offensively he has been a consistent contributor with 2008 being one of the most productive in his career. His 2008 season sparked controversy and led league officials to believe Sidoti may have been on PEDs. However, the league could find no evidence of Sidoti violating the league's drug policy. Sidoti strives to get the Goodfellas to their first league title and is prepared for the 2012 season.

Notable Achievements:

• 2008 Clutch Performer of the Year 
• Mr. Consistent 2008
• Co. Mr. September 2008
   

2012 Season:
Game 1: 0/3 
Game 2: 2/3, 2RBI - POG